If you're craving a festive treat without buying actual eggnog, this bold, ultra-cozy eggnog poke cake is about to become your new holiday tradition! Made with vanilla pudding, warm spices, and a buttery yellow cake, this dessert delivers all the classic flavor with none of the fuss.
Save This Recipe to Your Inbox
Enter your email and we’ll send this recipe straight to your inbox.
By signing up, you’ll join our email list and can unsubscribe anytime.
This easy eggnog poke cake recipe comes together with pantry staples and a boxed cake mix, making it perfect for budget-friendly celebrations. The creamy pudding mixture soaks into every bite, giving that old-fashioned custardy flavor people can't stop talking about.
The best part? This recipe tastes like old fashioned eggnog poke cake, but without needing any actual eggnog. Warm nutmeg, cinnamon, and a hint of rum extract recreate the flavor perfectly.
Whether you're hosting a party or just need a simple make-ahead dessert, this eggnog poke cake is holiday magic in a pan.
Jump to:
💛 Why You'll Love This Recipe
- The best shortcut holiday dessert. A boxed mix + pantry spices = a foolproof dessert that tastes 100% homemade.
- No real eggnog required. Perfect if you don't enjoy drinking eggnog but love the nostalgic flavor.
- Make-ahead friendly. This cake gets better as it chills, making it ideal for parties and potlucks.
🛒 Ingredients
- Yellow cake mix - Gives the soft, buttery base that soaks up the pudding beautifully.
- Instant vanilla pudding - The "eggnog custard" that fills every bite.
- Nutmeg + cinnamon - Classic eggnog spices that bring warmth and holiday flavor.
- Rum extract - Optional, but gives the most authentic eggnog aroma without adding alcohol.
- Whipped topping - Makes a light, fluffy finish over the chilled cake.
See the recipe card below for full ingredients and instructions.
🔀 Substitutions & Variations
Cake Mix: You can use white cake mix instead of yellow; it gives a lighter flavor, but yellow cake provides a richer, more old-fashioned base that pairs beautifully with spices.
Whipped Topping: Homemade whipped cream works great if you want a less sweet finish; stabilize it with 1 tablespoon of dry pudding mix so it holds up in the fridge.
Salted Caramel: Drizzle with my 10 Minute Salted Caramel Sauce for a luxurious eggnog poke cake with salted caramel twist that tastes like a bakery dessert.
💰 Budget-Friendly Tips
Use store-brand cake mix to save $1-2 per recipe with zero flavor difference.
Buy spices in bulk around the holidays; nutmeg and cinnamon go on sale and last all year.
Swap whipped topping for homemade when heavy cream is cheaper (often around Thanksgiving/Christmas!).
Make it potluck-style: One pan easily serves 12-16 people, keeping the cost per serving extremely low.
🥄 Instructions for Eggnog Poke Cake
Step 1: Mix and bake the yellow cake according to package instructions in a greased 9×13 pan. (Images 1 & 2) Let it cool for about 10 minutes. It should be warm but not piping hot. (Image 3)
Step 2: Use the handle of a wooden spoon to poke deep holes across the cake. The bigger the hole, the creamier each bite will be. (Image 4)
Step 3: Whisk vanilla pudding, milk, nutmeg, cinnamon, vanilla extract, and rum extract until slightly thickened; it should be pourable but not soupy. (Image 5)
Step 4: Slowly pour the pudding over the warm cake, spreading it into the holes so it sinks in. Chill for at least 1 hour. (Image 6)
Step 5: Spread whipped topping over the chilled cake (Image 7) and dust lightly with nutmeg. (Image 8)
Step 6: Chill again (optional but recommended). Refrigerate at least 2-3 hours to deepen the flavor and help the pudding fully set.
👩🏻🍳 Expert Tips
- Don't Let the Pudding Over-Thicken: Once the pudding gets too set, it won't seep down into the holes. Pour while still pourable.
- Pour Over a Warm Cake: A warm cake absorbs the pudding much better than a cooled cake.
- Make Deep Holes: Shallow pokes won't create those dramatic pudding streaks in every slice.
- Chill Overnight for Best Results: The flavor deepens and the texture becomes richer and creamier.
- Go Easy on Nutmeg: It's strong. Start with the recipe amount, then adjust to taste next time.
- Use a Warm Knife to Slice: Run your knife under hot water and wipe dry for clean, smooth cuts.
❄️ Storage and Make Ahead
Storage: Keep covered in the refrigerator for 3-4 days. The flavors get even better by day two.
Make Ahead: You can make the entire cake 24 hours in advance. For the best topping texture, add the whipped topping the morning you plan to serve.
🥗 Side Dishes or Pairing Ideas
This Eggnog Poke Cake pairs perfectly with my Slow Cooker Apple Cider or Dairy Free Crock Pot Hot Chocolate. For a fuller dessert table, add Christmas Kitchen Sink Cookies or slices of my festive Sourdough Pumpkin Roll.
- Crockpot Apple Cider RecipeRecipe $3.98 / Serving $0.40
- Dairy Free Crock Pot Hot ChocolateRecipe $4.50 / Serving $0.38
- Christmas Kitchen Sink CookiesRecipe $7.68 / Serving $0.43
- Sourdough Pumpkin RollRecipe $3.78 / Serving $0.38
❓ Recipe FAQs
Yes! Replace up to half the milk with eggnog. Using all the eggnog can make the pudding overly thick, so keep at least 1 cup milk.
The seasonings can create a chunky texture in the instant pudding if you take too long to stir everything together. For a more cohesive texture, whisk the dry seasonings with the dry pudding before adding the milk.
You can freeze the cake without the whipped topping. Add the topping after thawing for best texture.
Yes, just use a gluten-free yellow cake mix and double check that your pudding is GF.
🍽️ More Recipes You'll Love
- Chocolate Pistachio Bundt CakeRecipe $6.93 / Serving $0.58
- Southern Banana Pudding CakeRecipe $9.95 / Serving $0.62
- Tres Leches Layered CakeRecipe $18.24 / Serving $1.14
- Cake Mix Coffee CakeRecipe $3.46 / Serving $0.22
🐝 If you tried this Eggnog Poke Cake, please leave a ⭐️ star rating and share your buzz in the 💬 comments below. I'd truly appreciate it!
📖 Recipe
Eggnog Poke Cake
Equipment
- 9×13 baking pan
- Wooden Spoon (for poking holes)
Ingredients
- 1 box (15.25 ounces) yellow cake mix, plus ingredients called for on the package - ($1.90)
Eggnog Pudding Filling
- 2 boxes (3.4 ounces) instant vanilla pudding mix - ($1.96)
- 3 cups cold milk - ($0.48)
- 1 ½ teaspoons ground nutmeg - ($0.12)
- ½ teaspoon cinnamon - ($0.04)
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract - ($0.04)
- ¼-½ teaspoon rum extract, optional - ($0.14)
Topping
- 1 tub (8 ounces) whipped topping, thawed - ($0.98)
- Ground nutmeg, for dusting - ($0.02)
Instructions
- Bake the cake. Prepare and bake the yellow cake according to package directions in a greased 9×13-inch baking dish. Let cool for about 10 minutes until warm but not hot.
- Poke holes. Use the handle of a wooden spoon to poke deep holes evenly across the cake.
- Mix the pudding. Whisk the pudding mix, milk, nutmeg, cinnamon, vanilla extract, and rum extract if using until slightly thickened but still pourable.
- Fill the cake. Slowly pour the pudding mixture over the warm cake, spreading it so it sinks into the holes. Refrigerate for at least 1 hour.
- Top and chill. Spread the whipped topping evenly over the cake and dust lightly with nutmeg. Refrigerate for 2 to 3 hours if time allows.
Notes
- Warm cake. Pouring the pudding over a warm cake helps it sink deeper for a creamier texture.
- Pudding texture. The mixture should be slightly thickened but pourable so it fills the holes properly.
- Chilling. One hour is the minimum, but longer chilling improves flavor and structure.
- Make ahead. This dessert sets beautifully overnight and is ideal for holiday prep.
Nutritional Information
Save This Recipe to Your Inbox
Enter your email and we'll send this recipe straight to your inbox.
By signing up, you'll join our email list and can unsubscribe anytime.
Nicole Durham says
This eggnog poke cake is one of our favorites during the holidays because it's so simple and easy to make, a perfect no-worries dessert when we have dinner guests.